Donna Rentmeister

Board Member

Donna is a local entrepreneur with a thriving insurance business.  She opened her agency with American Family Insurance 17 years ago. She is a nationally ranked sales leader, has been recognized by JD Powers for outstanding customer service, and received the American Star Excellence in Customer Experience Award.  

Donna attributes much of her success to the passion she has for community involvement and events.  She believes that volunteering gives one a sense of purpose.  She has served in many community-facing roles both professionally and personally.  Donna combines the fun of making memories with friends and families with raising funds for meaningful causes. 

While Donna is proud of the success she’s had in business, her highest achievement is the incredible life she’s built with her husband of 34 years, their two children, and their three grandchildren.